Abe through the Japanese editorial lens

Filed under: Trans-Pacific Radio, Shasetsu - Op/Ed
Posted by Ken Worsley at 1:22 am on Thursday, October 19, 2006

What does the Japanese press have to say about the performance of new Prime Minister Shinzo Abe thus far? I’ve dug in and found some pieces that ordinarily wouldn’t get translated into English. I have a perspective from each of Japan’s three largest daily newspapers: The Asahi Shimbun, the Nihon Keizai Shimbun and the Yomiuri Shimbun.

The Asahi is generally spoken of as Japan’s most liberal daily broadsheet, the Nihon Keizai Shimbun (literally Japan Economic Newspaper) could be considered Japan’s version of the Wall Street Times Journal, and the Yomiuri is generally touted as Japan’s conservative voice. The Yomiuri has the largest daily circulation of any newspaper in the world. Here’s what they each had to say:

Asahi Shimbun

“Youthfulness, cleanliness, and a spirit to challenge” - these are the words often used by Abe’s supporters to describe his new cabinet. Unfortunately, none of these words seem to fit the new regime. “Cronyism” is more like it, as important cabinet and party leadership positions went to those folks who had supported Abe in the LDP presidential election. The makeup of this new leadership looks more like a new version of NHK’s weekly drama Komyo ga tsuji.

Nihon Keizai Shimbun

We are concerned with Abe’s views on history. While each individual is entitled to their own opinion, the prime minister of Japan cannot get away with seeming vague about his thoughts concerning the justifications of past wars. His personal views must not take precedence over national interests. He must speak and act with caution on all matters of history.

Yomiuri Shimbun

The prime minister has insisted that Japan steer away from its “postwar regime” by announcing that his cabinet would start work on a detailed schedule for amending the Constitution within five years. A new Constitution can serve as the compass in navigating the nation’s future as it struggles to overcome challenges of historic proportion.

As one might expect, the Asahi Shimbun has come out with harsh words on Abe’s cabinet choices. The paper failed to mention Abe’s appointment of five special advisors; this observer has argued in Seijigiri that these special advisors will lay out the backbone of the Prime Minister’s policy agenda.

The Nihon Keizai Shimbun, as an economic broadsheet might, focuses on the diplomatic aspects of Abe’s young tenure. This seems natural, since Abe’s ability (or inability) to normalize relations with China and South Korea will have a direct impact on Japan’s international business operations.

Finally, the Yomiuri, seemingly unable to find words of praise for Abe, declares that a ‘new Constitution’ will anchor Japan as it goes through historic challenges. We are not told what these historic challenges might be, but this observer worries about the consequences of them happening on Abe’s watch. Thus far, the Yomiuri has been lukewarm on Abe’s performance, also having offered a criticism of his statements concerning reforms needed to Japan’s medical establishment made in his October 2nd policy speech to the diet.
Listen Now:


icon for podpress  Shasetsu #4: Abe in the editorials: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

Related Posts:

13 Comments »

Comments may be subject to moderation and/or approval before appearing. There is no need to post the same comment twice. The site moderator may remove any comment he or she deems inappropriate, without notice.

187

Comment by Scott

October 19, 2006 @ 9:28 am

Kenzo and Garret,
Enjoying the opinions thus far. Keep up the good work. As for my “noble quest”, fruitless. I do believe that N. Korea has done the “nuclear testing” has a plea for attention. However, I think theyare going about it the wrong way. The UN would be a valuable asset to them if they used it properly. Although, the UN is one of the most corrupt entities in the world (but thats another topic).

188

Comment by Steve McClure

October 19, 2006 @ 10:23 am

Good stuff, although the correct name of the paper is the Wall Street Journal.

Ganbatte!

Steve

189

Comment by ken

October 19, 2006 @ 1:29 pm

Hey Steve, thanks for pointing that out! I was a bit tired when I put that one up. Perhaps there’s a rebel paper called the Wall Street Times out there somewhere…

191

Comment by DeOrio

October 19, 2006 @ 5:41 pm

Scott,
Thanks for the support. If, as you think (a number of observers agree with you), Kim Jong Il tested a nuke to get attention, it worked.
I don’t know how much help the UN could be, for a myriad of reasons, corruption being one, not having structures in place to engage while avoiding war being another one.
If your “noble quest” succeeds, can I come to the Pulitzer party? More power to you for trying.

194

Comment by Scott

October 19, 2006 @ 9:33 pm

i just noticed that my message was marked 187. There must have been a murder at the time of that posting! Make sure Kin Jun is still alive. One of his lts might have taken matters into his own hands.

196

Comment by Ken

October 19, 2006 @ 10:33 pm

Scott,
I think this will be post 195. A google image search for \’195\’ brought up this gentleman, who may be tied in with your post.

As for the quest, I figure we can rent a Cessna, or a hot air balloon, and head over there ourselves with a second-hand geiger counter.

197

Comment by DeOrio

October 19, 2006 @ 10:48 pm

Ken,
Check your link. I saw a nun as the first human in a photo under “195.” Sorry to screw up your comment, but you were 196, which is a young woman from Cambodia named Arrakeen, or possibly Phuong. I’m not sure.
Count me in on the balloon thing. Or the Cessna thing. Why a second-hand Geiger counter, though?

198

Comment by Ken Worsley

October 19, 2006 @ 11:22 pm

Mr DeOrio,

That photo was indeed taken from a Google image search for ‘195.’ If you must know, it was several pages deep into the search. I also checked for ‘196,’ but failed to find anyone toting an assault weapon. I did see the picture you speak of. In fact, picture 195 on that site can be seen here. Note the name of the picture. I wonder if we have perhaps been led to a site belonging to one of John Mark Karr’s friends. I blame Scott.

207

Comment by John Sheridan

October 20, 2006 @ 6:47 pm

So what does the average person think of him? Any news/polls out on that yet?

Seemed like Koizumi has so much charisma it distracted from what problems he had. Abe hardly looks enthusuastic - I wonder if the public feels that way?

220

Comment by Steve Schapiro

October 21, 2006 @ 12:30 am

Yeah, John, I know. What a dud! There’s a lot to be said for charisma and being able to get things done. I can’t imagine that Abe would ever be as popular as Koizumi.
I thought Japan had learned a lesson from US politics and gotten into putting charismatic guys up, but Abe is proof that they haven’t.

223

Comment by Andrea

October 21, 2006 @ 2:46 am

Steve, the US system hasn’t produced the best candidates. Look at your current “President”. Abe has been Prime Minister only for a few weeks so you can’t just his charismatic-ness yet. Just so you know, a lot of people here didn’t like Koizumi, so maybe Abe will be a good change.

256

Comment by ken

October 21, 2006 @ 10:25 am

Hey John, there’s something on Abe’s popularity up at What Japan Thinks. It’s a translation from a Japanese newspaper. I’m look for more stuff myself as well…will post anything I come across here.

257

Comment by John Sheridan

October 21, 2006 @ 3:28 pm

Thanks…interesting looking site. Kind of opened up the can of worms…I’ll have to check that out after I get up tomorrow.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>