TPR News: Saturday, March 31, 2007 - World War II, more World War II, and Lindsay Ann Hawker, R.I.P.

Filed under: Trans-Pacific Radio, TPR News
Posted by Garrett DeOrio at 9:38 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2007

In this edition of TPR News, we look at the ongoing political problems related to the Japanese government’s handling of issues related to World War II, the continued good health of amakudari, the gas between Japan and China, bread and beer, and the murder of Miss Lindsay Ann Hawker.

Politics

Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao is set to visit Tokyo from April 11th to 13th, just after visiting South Korea, and the kantei seems intent on filling the air with tension before he arrives.

In 1978, Yasukuni Shrine decided to add 14 convicted Class A war criminals, including wartime Prime Minister Hideki Tojo, to the two-and-a-half million spirits enshrined therein and drew harsh criticism for Japan from its Asian neighbors. The government’s way out of such entanglements has always been to point out that Yasukuni has been independent of the government since the end of World War II and acted on its own. This is still true, but documents released by the National Diet Library on Wednesday have shown that officials of the former Health Ministry discussed the controversial enshrinement with the Shrine in 1969.

Predictably, and quite possibly accurately, Abe and Chief Cabinet Secretary Yasuhisa Shiozaki, in separate statements, said they saw nothing wrong with the meeting, that it did not violate the separation of state and religion mandated by the Constitution.

The revelation casts renewed doubts over the role of the government in the actions and stances of the Shrine and its museum, the Yushukan, and follows closely on the heels of Abe’s recent remarks in response to the possibility of a US House resolution calling on Japan to apologize for enslaving thousands of women in sexual servitude during World War II, in which the Prime Minister used a tortured semantic argument to less than fully acknowledge Japan’s responsibility for what it did.

As Abe’s low approval ratings have shown, for one reason or another, a growing segment of the population is not behind him. A petition handed to the government on Thursday shows that at least some of the Prime Minister’s unpopularity is due to his stances on issues stemming from World War II. In it, over 14,400 people, the majority of whom were Japanese, called on the Prime Minister to issue a new apology to the comfort women and provide them with compensation.

In the book Oral History: Asian Women’s Fund, slated for publication this week by the Asian Women’s Fund, whose work officially ends today, House of Representatives Speaker Yohei Kono is quoted as defending the statement he issued in 1993, as Chief Cabinet Secretary, acknowledging the government’s role in the sexual enslavement of thousands of women during World War II, by saying, “It is not intellectually sincere to discuss this as if there had been no ‘comfort women’ issue,” targeting critics of what is known as the “Kono Statement.”

He pointed out obvious things, such as the possibility of the Army or the Government having destroyed documents - a possibility apparently not entertained by the Prime Minister or those who share his view of history - and said, “I have no intention of evading responsibility (for issuing the statement.) I have absolutely no intention of withdrawing it, either.”

China tried to make progress in its dispute with Japan over gas exploration rights in the East China Sea by tabling a proposal for joint development in order to try to get things moving in a stalemated process. Both countries agree that the answer to the problem is joint development of the area, but disagree on where the demarcation line between their territories is and where such development should take place.

If, as the government and Prime Minister say, amakudari, descent from Heaven, the golden parachute, is on the way out, it’s sure had one heck of a last fling. The ranks of retired bureaucrats collecting top salaries for watching the clock from cushy chairs in the private sector swelled by 5,789 in 2006, bringing the total to 27,882 fallen angels at 4,576 firms, an increase of 589 from 2005.

It’s not such a bad deal for the firms that employ retired bureaucrats, though. Apparently having one’s former colleagues employed at relevant firms makes bureaucrats jobs cushier, too, and everyone benefits. Except taxpayers, of course. Firms employing retired bureaucrats received 4.89 trillion yen in state subsidies in just the first half of fiscal 2006. In addition, such firms were able to avoid bidding processes to receive 1.8001 trillion yen in contracts for state projects, 98% of the total. Percentages for individual ministries went up to 99.99% for the Ministry of Finance. (For a more detailed breakdown by ministry, click here.)

While Abe has submitted proposals to the Diet to change the system, these proposals will have little real effect, it seems. Under the kantei’s proposals, a goernmental “human resources bank” would be created to arrange jobs for retiring bureaucrats and would be allowed to employ retired bureaucrats iself. However, retired bureaucrats working in the human resources bank would be prohibited from arranging jobs for people who had worked in the same ministries or agencies as them. That meager safeguard disappeared in the face of LDP opposition, though, which means nothing will be changed. I’d make the Last Word, but it’s not even really an opinion. Nothing is changing. Amakudari and the shadowy practices that go along with it are alive, well, and in no danger of disappearing.

Camaigning in the April unified elections is in full swing and deserves more attention than it can be given here. Look to the upcoming Seijigiri #21 and other articles on TPR for information.

Business and the Economy

Yamazaki Baking is set to become Fujiya’s largest shareholder, and thereby take control over the embattled confectionery maker. In an announcement made on Tuesday, it was revealed that Yamazaki will purchase a 35 percent stake in Fujiya for about 16 billion yen. The companies have stated that Yamazaki will lend better corporate governance and help Fujiya ensure that sanitation standards are followed. Last weekend, Fujiya resumed limited sales of its cakes at about 30% of its shops nationwide. Due to a significant number of employees leaving after food safety scandals came to light in January, the company is currently unable to operate at 100% retail capacity.

On Thursday, the shareholders of Sapporo Breweries voted to approve an ‘Advance Warning System’ that will provide the company’s board of directors with the means to thwart takeover attempts. The move is intended to prevent a takeover bid from US based hedge fund Steel Partners, which is currently the largest single shareholder in Sapporo, and campaigned strongly against the approval of the ‘Advance Warning System.’

Earlier this week, Keidanren proposed that skilled foreign workers be allowed to receive temporary full-time working positions at Japanese companies in areas where workers are in demand. The business lobby organization asserted that skilled workers in industries such as sheet metal processing, welding and shipbuilding, who are currently unable to receive work visas, should be made eligible for the program. Keidanren also said that foreign workers should be required to demonstrate “certain levels of Japanese language ability,” and that their period of stay should be limited to one or three years.

Soichiro Chigusa, the president of The president of Kansai Telecasting Corporation, or KTV, in Osaka, will reportedly announce his resignation sometime early next week. Chigusa’s resignation is intended to take responsibility for a scandal that saw producers at KTV using fabricated data in their television programs, including one episode which contained 16 instances of misinformation, including eight fabrications of data with one on the dietary benefits of natto fermented soybeans. Other episodes included voice-overs of foreign scientists with false translations of their words. According to the Yomiuri, Chigusa’s successor will likely be chosen from among the broadcaster’s executives.

Society

On Thursday, the Nagoya Disrict Court rejected a suit filed by 168 people displaced at the end of World War II. In the complaint, the plaintiffs claimed that the Japanese government lacked a sufficient policy to bring them back to Japan at the end of the War, generally after having been separated from their parents, and offered insufficient assistance, such as language training, to allow them to live normal lives after their return to Japan.

The suit was the fifth such suit to receive a ruling out of fifteen suits filed by about 2,200 people in similar circumstances. Last December’s decision by the Kobe District Court that the government failed in is responsibilities and had to pay 61 of 65 plaintiffs a total of 468.6 million yen, has been the only decision not in the government’s favor.

A number of the war-displaced have recently begun publicizing their stories and have received assistance from a variety of charities and non-profit groups, such as the Japan-China Friendship Association. The Narrative Group of Settlers in Manchuria and Mongolia, a group that attempts to propagate and record the stories of the war-displaced and settlers of Japan’s wartime colonies and puppet states, is attempting to find both funding and a location for a museum that would perform such functions.

Many Japanese nationals stranded in Manchuria or Inner Mongolia were unable to return to Japan until after Japan normalized relations with China in 1972 and others were unable to visit Japan to search for their relations until Japan organized group tours for such a purpose in 1981.

While we normally don’t cover individual crimes, and certainly don’t want to imply that the nationality of either the victim or the perpetrator makes any crime more or less heinous or noteworthy, the recent murder of 22-year-old British Nova teacher Lindsay Ann Hawker in Ichikawa, Chiba has generated interest and debate that range well beyond most other murders and touches on issues that are relevant to a number of topics well within the purview of TPR News’s normal reporting.

While the details of what led up to Miss Hawker’s murder have yet to be fully cleared up, the story so far is that the recent graduate of the University of Leeds had been at Nova for just over five months, had been harassed and stalked by someone, possibly the killer, and had gone to the apartment of 28-year-old Tatsuya Ichihashi to teach a private lesson.

It is reported that Miss Hawker, who had told friends back in England that she intended to leave Japan because she found Japanese men “creepy,” had been stopped by a man at Gyotoku station, where both she and Ichihashi lived, and was asked for her name, phone number, and private English lessons. She refused and rode away on a bicycle. The man, apparently in good shape, followed her home. Details are blurry, but apparently, with her roommates at home, she allowed the man into her apartment for a drink of water.

In Ichihashi’s apartment, at the time of the murder, she was beaten, bound, strangled, suffocated, and buried in sand in a bathtub placed on the balcony of Ichihashi’s apartment - apparently in that order. Neighbors told police they had heard scraping and dragging sounds emanating from Ichihashi’s apartment, apparently from the bathtub being removed and dragged out onto the balcony.

When Ichihashi was confronted by police in front of his apartment, he apparently affirmed that he was in fact Tatsuya Ichihashi, then fled barefooted down the fire escape, losing pursuing officers at an intersection.

Miss Hawker’s father and boyfriend arrived in Japan to claim her body and gave a tearful statement to the press, asking people to help the police apprehend the killer.

Ichihashi is the primary and, it seems, only suspect in the case.

All of us here at Trans-Pacific Radio join the rest of our community here - both on line and off, both Japanese and foreign - in offering our sincere condolences to Miss Hawker’s family and friends.

Listen Now:


icon for podpress  TPR News: 3/31/07: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

Related Posts:

4 Comments »

Comments may be subject to moderation and/or approval before appearing. There is no need to post the same comment twice. The site moderator may remove any comment he or she deems inappropriate, without notice.

Comment by BACKGROUND OF 'COMFORT WOMEN' ISSUE

April 2, 2007 @ 8:29 am

BACKGROUND OF ‘COMFORT WOMEN’ ISSUE / Comfort station originated in govt-regulated ‘civilian prostitution’

http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/dy/national/20070331dy01.htm

The Yomiuri Shimbun

Controversy over the so-called comfort women has been inflamed again. The U.S. House of Representatives has been deliberating a draft resolution calling for the Japanese government to apologize over the matter by spurning the practice as slavery and human trafficking. Why has such a biased view of the issue prevailed? The Yomiuri Shimbun carried in-depth reports on the issue Tuesday. The writers are Masanobu Takagi, Hiroaki Matsunaga and Emi Yamada of the political news department. Starting today, The Daily Yomiuri will carry the stories in three installments.

To discuss the comfort women issue, it is indispensable to understand the social background of the time when prostitution was authorized and regulated by the government in Japan. Prostitution was tacitly permitted in limited areas up until 1957, when the law to prevent prostitution was enforced.

Comfort women received remuneration in return for sexual services at so-called comfort stations for military officers and soldiers. According to an investigation report publicized by the government on Aug. 4, 1993, on the issue of comfort women recruited into sexual service for the Japanese military, there is a record mentioning the establishment of such a brothel in Shanghai around 1932, and additional similar facilities were established in other parts of China occupied by the Imperial Japanese Army.

Some of them were under the direct supervision of the military authorities, but many of the brothels catering to soldiers were privately operated.

Modern historian Ikuhiko Hata, a former professor at Nihon University, says the comfort women system should be defined as the “battleground version of civilian prostitution.”

Comfort women were not treated as “paramilitary personnel,” unlike jugun kangofu (military nurses) and jugun kisha (military correspondents). During the war, comfort women were not called “jugun ianfu” (prostitutes for troops). Use of such generic terminology spread after the war. The latter description is said to have been used by writer Kako Senda (1924-2000) in his book titled “Jugun Ianfu” published in 1973. Thereafter, the usage of jugun ianfu prevailed.

In addition to Japanese women, women from the Korean Peninsula and Taiwan, both then under Japanese colonial rule, and China, the Philippines, Indonesia and other countries invaded by the Imperial Japanese Army were recruited as comfort women.

Hata estimates that 40 percent of the wartime comfort women were Japanese, 30 percent Chinese and other nationalities and 20 percent Korean.

The total number of comfort women has yet to be determined exactly.

According to a report compiled by Radhika Coomaraswany of the U.N. Commission on Human Rights in 1996, there were 200,000 comfort women from the Korean Peninsula alone. The figure in the report was based on information Coomaraswany had obtained in North Korea. But this report contained many factual errors, and its quoted sources lacked impartiality. Foreign Minister Taro Aso rejected the figure of 200,000 as “lacking objective evidence.”

The reasons cited for the need for comfort women and wartime brothels are as follows:

– To prevent military officers and soldiers from raping women and committing other sex crimes in occupied areas.

– To prevent venereal disease from spreading through troops who would otherwise contact local prostitutes who did not receive periodic medical checks.

– To prevent military secrets from being leaked by limiting the women who provided sexual services to officers and soldiers to recruited comfort women.

Such a system and the use of wartime brothels generally are not limited only to the Imperial Japanese military.

The U.S. troops that occupied Japan after the war used brothels provided by the Japanese side. There was a case in which U.S. military officials asked the Japanese authorities to provide women for sexual services. During the Vietnam War, brothels similar to those established for the former Japanese military were available to U.S. troops, a U.S. woman journalist has pointed out.

Hata said: “There were wartime brothels also for the German troops during World War II. Some women were forced into sexual slavery. South Korean troops had brothels during the Korean War, according to a finding by a South Korean researcher.”

(Mar. 31, 2007)

Comment by ken

April 3, 2007 @ 1:14 am

Why has such a biased view of the issue prevailed?

First, it’s not math. It’s history and politics, and everything written on it is biased in some way.

But the real problem: PR slip-ups from the Japanese government. An inability to handle the issue in a consistent manner, to even appear sincere in thought and deed, and most of all: allowing themselves to be baited by the media. They have no one else to blame.

Comfort women received remuneration in return for sexual services at so-called comfort stations for military officers and soldiers.

This claim is unsubstantiated by evidence. It may well be true in all cases, some cases, one case or none. How does the author plan to back this up?

The total number of comfort women has yet to be determined exactly.

It’s impossible to do so, and also completely irrelevant.

According to a report compiled by Radhika Coomaraswany of the U.N. Commission on Human Rights in 1996, there were 200,000 comfort women from the Korean Peninsula alone…this report contained many factual errors, and its quoted sources lacked impartiality.

For example? What empirical evidence of this claim does the Yomiuri have to offer?

Such a system and the use of wartime brothels generally are not limited only to the Imperial Japanese military.

Is that supposed to excuse the action? What a morally bankrupt argument. The article points out that other nations engaged in enforced sexual slavery. This is true.

Hold them all accountable. The fact that it happened elsewhere does not make it ok. The fact that it happened in other wars does not make sexual slavery any less wrong. This argument that ‘others did it too’ is akin to rationalizations that eight year old children put forth in the principal’s office: lacking in both world view and self awareness.

Arguments such as this do more to hurt their cause than support it, since they are based on what essentially amounts to a guilty plea.

Pingback by Rocking in Hakata » Stalking Bandwagon

April 10, 2007 @ 2:46 pm

[…] Ok - let me just say, in defense of Japanese men, that they are not all freaky, perverted, and exponentially randier with every year they add to their lives. But you sure would think otherwise if you followed some foreign media coverage after the recent Lindsay Hawker murder. For those who don’t know about the Lindsay Hawking murder, please refer to Trans-Pacific Radio’s coverage of it. (It’s in the “Society” section.) They link to some other resources there. (You can also check any newspaper that covered it.) […]

Comment by Ken Y-N

April 12, 2007 @ 10:43 am

I’ve only just got round to listening to this story, and perhaps you might be interested in a recent opinion poll on Amakudari:

http://www8.cao.go.jp/survey/tokubetu/h18/h18-koumuin.pdf

I tried translating it but the last question was too difficult for me!

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>