Agriculture Minister Matsuoka Buys the Farm (松岡が自殺した。)

Filed under: Japan in the News
Posted by Garrett DeOrio at 4:54 pm on Monday, May 28, 2007

In the “Last Word” appended to the most recent edition of TPR News, I asked:

What do you do when you’re an outrageous liar and everyone knows it,and you know everyone knows it, and they know that you know, etc.?

I went on to say that, if you were Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries Toshikatsu Matsuoka, you would continue to lie and laugh as Prime Minister Abe continued to defend you, continued to claim you’d answered questions right after you’d refused to do so.

Well, there’s one more step you would take were you Matsuoka. The last one.

We here at TPR had called for Matsuoka to leave, but we didn’t think it would happen like it did. Shortly after noon today, Mr. Matsuoka was found in his government apartment by an aide. He was unconscious, having hanged himself, and died in hopital shortly thereafter, apparently without ever regaining consciousness.

From Nikkei:

Farm Minister Dies In Apparent Suicide, Dealing Heavy Blow To Abe Govt

TOKYO (Nikkei)–Agriculture Minister Toshikatsu Matsuoka died Monday at a Tokyo hospital after being found to have hanged himself in an apparent suicide, police said. He was 62.

The death of Matsuoka, who had been under fire for his dubious use of political funds, comes as a major blow to the government of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, which is preparing for the upper house election scheduled for July.

Matsuoka came under fierce criticism when it was revealed that his funds management body booked utility costs as political expenses. Even some within his own ruling Liberal Democratic Party called for his resignation.

On the day of his death, the minister had talks with his secretary in his residence for Diet members in Tokyo’s Akasaka district until around 10 a.m. When Matsuoka failed to come out of his 11th floor room after the meeting, the secretary went back in to check on him, only to find the minister unconscious. The secretary and other staff members sent Matsuoka to the hospital, but efforts to resuscitate him failed.

Scandals plagued Matsuoka from the outset of his tenure as farm minister. When the accounting scandal came to light immediately after he took the post, Matsuoka denied any wrongdoing, saying, “The expenses were neither fictitious nor a cover for something else.” The prime minister repeatedly defended the embattled minister, saying at one point, “I see no problem.”

Earlier this month, Matsuoka came under suspicion for his possible involvement in bid rigging related to the government-affiliated Japan Green Resources Agency (J-Green), prompting some fellow LDP lawmakers to call for his resignation.

Matsuoka was elected to the lower house six times from the third electoral district of Kumamoto Prefecture on the southern Japanese main island of Kyushu. He became a cabinet member for the first time with his appointment as farm minister by Abe in September 2006.

(The Nikkei Monday evening edition)

The suicide of any high profile politician, especially one beset by scandal for six months, opens the door to a great deal of speculation, not least about the timing of his suicide, the role political opportunity played in it, how it will help or hinder the Prime Minister and the LDP or the opposition DPJ, and how and why Matsuoka held on and retained Abe’s support for so long after it became clear he was lying.

If you’re into that sort of thing, the next Seijigiri will be out earlier than usual - the domestic political scene will see a flurry of activity and the DPJ will have to toe the line between electioneering and being seen as insensitive. Most immediately, who will Abe apoint as Farm Minister? Chief Cabinet Secretary Shiozaki has already announced the speedy naming of a replacement.

Mr. Matsuoka was a liar and a crook, who insisted on dragging his scandal out when caught. This strategy brought some political gain to his party, but not to his country and, in the end, apparently not to his conscience, either.

To his family, we here at TPR extend our condolences - it is never the guilty who suffer, but those closest to him have gotten no reprieve.

Messrs. Honma and Sata, guilty of similar improprieties, resigned long ago. Let’s hope Mr. Ibuki, the highest-ranking of the remaining huddle of political fund report-fudgers, steps down less melodramatically, for everyone’s sake.


Related Posts:

19 Comments »

Comments may be subject to moderation and/or approval before appearing. There is no need to post the same comment twice. The site moderator may remove any comment he or she deems inappropriate, without notice.

Comment by Scott

May 28, 2007 @ 6:06 pm

I’m pretty sure it was “shortly after lunchtime today” not “shortly after midnight last night”.

Comment by ken

May 28, 2007 @ 8:40 pm

Thanks Scott, you’re right. After the 10am meeting, body found 18 mins after noon.

Trackback by Pajamas Media

May 28, 2007 @ 10:19 pm

Japanese Agriculture Minister Pushing Up Daisies:…

Plagued by corruption charges and calls for his resignation, Toshikatsu Matsuoka hung himself. “Mr. Matsuoka was a liar and a crook, who insisted on dragging his scandal out when caught. This strategy brought some political gain to his party, but……

Comment by japanese

May 29, 2007 @ 1:02 am

conpletely missing political situation and context in japna. pure amatuarish nonsense;

Comment by ken

May 29, 2007 @ 1:42 am

“Japanese”,

conpletely missing political situation and context in japna. pure amatuarish nonsense;

But not, my friend, anonymous cowards. And not without spell-check.

Good luck sorting out your insecurity complex!

By the way, you should know that your IP address, reverse DNS look-ups and a little cross-referencing gave your identity away. I expected better from you.

Comment by Ken Y-N

May 29, 2007 @ 10:09 am

I saw on the news this morning that the guy at J-Green or whoever was on the alleged fiddle in Kumamoto who killed himself last week was in fact an old school mate (同級生 was used) of Matsuoka.

Do you think Abe can survive the election? I saw him on telly this morning and he didn’t look so good. Any juicy details on the suicide notes - he left 8, apparently, but they only mentioned the contents of two.

Comment by ken

May 29, 2007 @ 12:34 pm

Ken, then another one this morning: http://www.nikkei.co.jp/news/main/20070529AT1G2900S29052007.html

How many makes an outbreak? J-Green sounds like such a nice organization…

Comment by tomojiro

May 29, 2007 @ 1:15 pm

I think that this event marks the beginning of the end of the Abe cabinet.

The problem is who comes next.

Comment by ken

May 29, 2007 @ 1:25 pm

Tomojiro and Ken YN -

I don’t necessarily think this has to be the end of the Abe Cabinet, though there’s a good chance (I’m hedging here, obviously…)

Who comes next is a big question, but I think there are three realistic candidates:

Taro Aso - Has been a fabulous Foreign Minister, but he doesn’t have broad party support and sticks his foot in his mouth too much when he’s in front of the cameras

Yasuhisa Shiozaki - Could continue in the Abe reform path

Junichiro Koizumi - Bring him back! This would be the feel-good choice, if he can legally do it

That said, so long as the LDP retains a majority in coalition in the Upper House, Abe probably isn’t going anywhere. And I still think they can do that. It’s going to come down to those 29 single-seat districts and the LDP will fight tooth and nail for them.

One of the reasons why Abe probably isn’t going anywhere is because, as Tomojiro seems to point out, there just isn’t anyone else available who can run the country.

Comment by DeOrio

May 29, 2007 @ 2:03 pm

I think there’s an argument to be made for this being damaging to the Cabinet, of course, but I also think this could help Abe and the restof his Cabinet. There’s going to be a period when the DPJ may well be too timid or too afraid of looking insensitive to really lay into crooked LDP members. The LDP could and will spin this to help them and hurt the DPJ, of course. We’ll probably start hearing rumbling about how the DPJ has nothing, so it hounds people.

I’m really interested in seeing what this story is. Apparently Mrs. Matsuoka knows. Was there something much larger than Matsuoka’s dishonesty at play? Could he have been protecting somehow? So many conspriacy theories to play with. . .

Abe’s not going anywhere just yet. If the LDP takes a big hit in July, then he should worry. Aso has no chance, as Ken pointed out (I’m not quite as sanguine about his performance as FM.) Tanigaki’s not making any noise. Shiozaki would seem to be in position, but he has to come into his own and show Nakagawa who the boss is, put forth a stronger presence in the Cabinet.

If I’m interpreting things correctly, Koizumi’s return would be legal, but barred by party rules, which were changed once for him already. If the LDP really wanted him back, they could change their own rules again, but I think that’s unlikely. Koizumi’s maverick spirit didn’t penetrate enough to create an actual reformist block in the Diet and there are a number of old horse traders who feel they should be given a crack at being PM because they’re old.

Pingback by Liberal Japan » Blog Archive » Toshikatsu Matsuoka commits suicide.

May 29, 2007 @ 2:42 pm

[…] There has been some excellent blogging on this at Observing Japan and TransPacificRadio. In particular, I’ve found several relevant posts at Observing Japan to be really helpful in understanding Matsuoka’s activities. […]

Comment by Cal Hobbs

May 30, 2007 @ 3:34 am

I am not sure that extending condolences to the family means a lot after calling a family member a liar and a crook.

“Hey, he was a liar and a cheat and a crook and a scoundrel and he was a disgrace to his country and family and name BUT we are sure you all thought he was swell.”

Nice gesture but it might be a bit empty?

Comment by Gen

May 30, 2007 @ 7:48 am

An excellent report concerning Matsuoka and his political life : http://epress.anu.edu.au/power_pork_citation.html

Comment by DeOrio

May 30, 2007 @ 11:01 am

The condolences are more for the general situation his family is in - as much for having been his family as for his death.
I do not believe in that hogwash about not speaking ill of the dead.

Pingback by Global Voices Online » Japan: "Thought Check" Screening for Citizen Judges

May 30, 2007 @ 4:31 pm

[…] While news in Japan this week was understandably fixated on the sensational suicide of Agriculture Minister Matsuoka Toshikatsu (and related scandals), as is often the case this country, another story — somewhat less sensational yet arguably at least as significant — slipped by without much notice. The story was brought up in a blog entry posted last Saturday at the “doko doko” blog of Diet member Nobuto Hosaka of the Social Democratic Party of Japan, the most active member in the House of Representatives (in terms of number of questions raised) and known for being a thorn in the side of the ruling party coalition. Saturday’s post concerned a new “citizen judge system” to be introduced in Japan by May 2009, one which would allow, for the first time in Japan’s history, a group of six citizen judges (along with 3 professional judges) to preside on cases involving verdicts as serious as the death penalty. (A simulation of the selection process for choosing citizen judges is already being carried out.) […]

Comment by ken

May 31, 2007 @ 12:18 am

I am not sure that extending condolences to the family means a lot after calling a family member a liar and a crook.

I don’t see how the two could be related in any way, shape or form.

Comment by ken

May 31, 2007 @ 1:33 am

There’s going to be a period when the DPJ may well be too timid or too afraid of looking insensitive to really lay into crooked LDP members. The LDP could and will spin this to help them and hurt the DPJ

True…the LDP could take a page right out of the Rove playbook. There are two potential situations:

1) The DPJ proceeds by being afraid of seeming insensitive.

In this situation, the LDP just needs to usurp their stance and say, “Why did they give up on this? Can you elect people who just give up?”

2) The DPJ proceeds by pushing and forcing the LDP to discuss the issues.

The LDP says that they are insensitive, insulting the dead and holding up procedures in an effort to ‘politicize’ the situation. Who would vote for such people?

It looks like they’re taking path #2. As the LDP decided to push through their bill on the pension system, DPJ President Ozawa refused to postpone his debate with Abe so that Abe could go down to Matsuoka’s funeral in Kumamoto. Abe whined to reporters about this, without mentioning that had the debate been postponed, he would have gone to Kumamoto and let the bill be pushed through without the debate, and without him being there. It’s getting harder to believe anything that comes out of this man’s mouth.

Pingback by Kanji of the Year 2007 » 世論 What Japan Thinks

December 12, 2007 @ 3:19 pm

[…] 90,816 people voted by internet, postcard and by attending the temple in person, and the top kanji chosen by them was 偽, nise, gi, meaning imitation, deception, or bogus. This year has been full of such stories; it started off with fake health benefits from natto, and continued with one scandal after another, from construction companies faking earthquake resistance to beef-free beef croquettes. This leads us to the number two choice, 食, shoku, food, where in addition to the ironically-named Meat Hope beef mentioned before, trusted souvenir brands Akafuku and Shiroi Koibito amongst others got caught reusing ingredients that had passed their expiry dates. To round out the bad news, third was 嘘, uso, lies, which claimed the life of one politician this year. […]

Pingback by The One With The Kanji Of The Year « So no one told you life was gonna be this way.

December 14, 2007 @ 4:04 pm

[…] It wasn’t really a shocking choice, given all the news stories this year, starting off with fake health benefits from natto, and continued with one scandal after another, from construction companies faking earthquake resistance to beef-free beef croquettes. Besides Japanese news reports faking reports on the health value of food, there were also various reports on Japanese TV stations faking programs, Japanese companies selling expired food, and foreign countries copying Japanese stuff. This in turn leads us to the number two choice, 食, shoku, food, where in addition to the ironically-named Meat Hope beef mentioned before, trusted souvenir brands Akafuku and Shiroi Koibito amongst others got caught reusing ingredients that had passed their expiry dates. To round out the bad news, third was 嘘, uso, lies, which claimed the life of one politician this year. Tsk tsk. […]

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>