Nova Protests, or lack thereof (+ Nova Strike Info), and Krispy Kreme vs. Burger King

Filed under: Trans-Pacific Info, Japan in the News
Posted by Garrett DeOrio at 8:01 pm on Monday, October 15, 2007

(Click the title or the “Read On. . .” tag and scroll to the bottom for strike details.)

With the whole Nova fiasco lighting up the Japan blogosphere and TPR, through the rapidly growing celebrity of our own Ken Worsley, finding ourselves at the center of the coverage of the issue, I found myself getting drawn further and further beyond the human interest interviews we did and the intrigue of the bizarre financial dealings punctuating the company’s decline and fall and more and more into an arena I will freely admit I had avoided previously - partially for lack of interest and. . . no, that’s it - almost entirely for lack of interest, not in the issue or the plight of Nova’s shafted employees and customers, but because the plethora of ad hominem attacks, the rumor-mongering, the scarcity of verifiable useful input, and the general mean-spirited and often misleading nature of much of the discussion in forums and on blogs detracts from what useful content there is and causes one to see the Saudi/Iranian/Chinese side of things on the issue of Internet control. (OK, I’m kidding.)

That said, I’ve spent about as much time on the Nova issue as nearly any non-Nova employee/ non-Ken Worsley over the past six weeks or so and came across something I had not expected: action.

Don’t get me wrong, the Nova Union guys have their hearts in the right place and have had some successes over the years, but it seems they just didn’t have the resources or the experience to handle anything on the scale of Nova’s collapse. In most forums and on most blogs, people claiming to represent Unions from here to Fukuoka kept chiming in to offer helpful advice and. . . discourage action. Now I’m sure those Union guys would disagree with my assessment of their contribution to the discussion, but time and again I saw the Union input serve as a wet blanket, which wouldn’t necessarily be bad except that the workers they’re supposed to be representing are in a situation more dire than the Union seems willing to admit. (”The Union” here being primarily Nambu, whose rebuttal I’d welcome.)

This is not a Union-bashing post, though. In fact, there’s a demonstration planned for tomorrow.

UPDATE:

According to an e-mail the General Union sent out, the Union will notify Nova that members will be striking tomorrow (Tuesday.) Strikers and their sympathizers will then meet at Okubo station on the JR Sobu line (one stop from Shinjuku) at 11:15 a.m., from which they’ll proceed to the Labor Standards Office to make statements to the press and picket for the prosecution of Saruhashi. The protest will be followed by a Union meeting to decide on the next step. To join the General Union, click this link. (For Nova employees, dues have been reduced to 1,000 yen a month until you find other work, which is cut-rate.)

I applaud this step, as it is specific and organized, which is exactly what Nova employees need to be right now. Best of luck to all of them.

Back to the story:

By stumbling upon The Nova Walkout, I learned there was also an abortive attempt to plan one for today. Impressive, thought I. Lots of comments, lots of passion, most in favor of the walkout. Even some useful information being bandied about. Commenters said they’d tell everyone they knew and fax the blog’s message to every branch.

Sounded great. Only problem was it was all talk. It appears no one bothered to take the lead, each person thinking someone else would get them all together and do all the work. It got to around noon today - a couple of days after employees learned their pay would be late and most started to accept that “Friday, the 19th” was probably a euphemism for “October 25th,” which probably pretty much meant never.

Plenty of indignation, no leadership, no action.

In my capacity here at TPR, it struck me as natural that I should find myself at the Shinjuku NS Building around 3:30 p.m. today - only half an hour after the show of Nova unity, employees showing they weren’t going to take it anymore and were going to contact the media to cover it was set to begin. On my way to Shinjuku, I stopped by Nakano Nova, whose separate kids’ school has now been reassumed into the main school. I tried to see in the windows, I went into the reception area - not much life. Shinjuku Honko was busier - I even saw an instructor and some customers, but the building’s windows, well lit and easy to see into from across the street, revealed no activity. Then I went to the NS Building. I did laps around the building, through the lobby, up and down the stairs, even into the Rose & Crown and saw only two Western-looking faces, a pair of travelers a bit lost in the building’s cavernous lobby. No protesters. Given that the building houses Nova’s Tokyo head office, seeing no Westerners and no one with the “Nova look” (not meant to to be disparaging, but the managers often seem to even wear their suits in a certain way), seemed a bit odd. Heck, I went into a faux-English pub in Shinjuku and saw no Westerners. That’s hard to do.

So, there was no protest. I’m guessing today’s event was too confused, too unplanned to be pulled off, which meant that it was subsumed by tomorrow’s Union-led action. Let’s hope so.

As I put this up, I hear that my first workplace in Japan, all those years ago, Nova Shimbashi, is set to close up tomorrow evening.

There was another interesting point to today, though. Finding myself in the skyscraper district, with some time to kill, I decided to finally hit the Burger King in Shinjuku iLand Tower. I’d had occasion to pass by it once, a couple of days after it opened, and saw an impressive line out front - long enough to make me pass on a burger. Far more often, I pass by the Krispy Kreme store on Shinjuku Southern Terrace, set up by Revamp, who, along with Lotte, is responsible for Burger King’s return to Japan. Even now, nine months after it opened, Krispy Kreme has lines stretching up onto the bridge to Takashimaya and waits of an hour or more just to get doughnuts. Krispy Kreme is set to open a second store in Yurakucho, which will surely also pull in groups of ladies in their hundreds. I’m guessing this was the hope for Burger King, too.

Not to be, though. At 5:00 p.m., there were two people ahead of me in line and maybe a dozen customers in the entire joint. I saw no take out orders in the half hour or so I was inside. Burger King, which I hadn’t had for ages, is in fact vastly superior to most of the other burger offerings in Tokyo (especially the bafflingly-highly-rated MOS Burger, which sucks - no other way to put it.) Nevertheless, if this evening’s situation - a nearly empty restaurant amid thousands of working people relaxing on benches and sidewalks and milling around in general - is typical, it looks like we might be saying goodbye to old BK for the second time in less than a decade.

TUESDAY STRIKE DETAILS:

Schedule of Events

Monday Oct 15: We will fax document to Nova management notifying them that all members will strike for the entire day Tuesday.

Tuesday 11 am: Meet at South Exit of Okubo Station on the Sohbu Line

See map: http://maps.google.co.jp/maps?oe=UTF-8&hl=ja&tab=wl&q=

We will then walk to the Shinjuku LSO at 11:15pm

11:30pm We will say a few words to the press and then enter the LSO with our petition to prosecute Pres. Sahashi.

12:00pm-12:30pm We will demonstrate outside LSO in front of press

12:30-13:00pm We will hold a brief press conference

13:15pm to 14:00pm We will hold a union meeting back at the union office to decide our next collective move.

Again, remember all members must strike on Tuesday since we will be notifying management that way. Since we have many new members, we can decide tomorrow what future actions to take. But it is crucial that we act as a union tomorrow, particularly when there will be press attention.

If you have any questions, please call Louis at 09093636580.

If you talk to the press, tell them to be at the Shinjuku LSO (Shinjuku Rohdoh Kijun Kantoku-Sho at 11:15pm).

Please feel free to agree or refuse to personal interviews with the press. Friends and supporters of Nova Union, including all Nambu members are welcome to join us for the whole day of action.

In Solidarity, Louis Carlet Dep. Gen. Sec. NUGW Tokyo Nambu

Bob Tench Vice President Nova Union

– NUGW Tokyo Nambu - Nambu FWC — Vote today for your favourite Nova mascot!
http://nambufwc.org


Related Posts:

13 Comments »

Comments may be subject to moderation and/or approval before appearing. There is no need to post the same comment twice. The site moderator may remove any comment he or she deems inappropriate, without notice.

Comment by Ken Worsley

October 15, 2007 @ 11:09 pm

Let me know when BK stops paying you.

Comment by DeOrio

October 15, 2007 @ 11:32 pm

OK, I will. You know, though, I didn’t even get any coupons or anything.

Comment by Shawn

October 16, 2007 @ 9:40 am

The rambling nature of your post is reflective of what’s going on: lots of confusion. It does seem like an every-man-for-himself situation. Everybody’s situation in Nova is different, and those who have been with the Nova the longest are gong to hurt the most. I think that’s why it has been difficult to get organized. It hard to fight for your rights when its easier to move on to another job and you don’t plan on staying in Japan for very long.

I wouldn’t be so dismissive of the signal to noise ratio of the (unnamed) forums. That’s where all of the real information on the Nova fiasco has be coming from. That’s where we’ve been getting information on school closures, evictions, paychecks, links to stories in the media, and pictures of Sahashi’s faxes.

The problem is that all of this is unfiltered and raw. But, when someone makes a claim about something, that bit of information is quickly shot down or supported by other readers. That’s the beauty of it all, but you have to pay attention and think about what information is valid and what is not.

That said, I think this is a defining moment for Nambu and eikaiwa. If teachers don’t organize themselves after this mess, then they probably never will. If they succeed, eikaiwa just may turn into something better.

P.S. Krispy Kreme and Burger King are garbage. How you eat that slop? It’s not food. ;-)

Trackback by Quiva Blog

October 16, 2007 @ 11:59 am

Krispy Kreme…

Just when you thought it was insane to queue for hours and hours to buy doughnuts, how about queuing for hours to buy doughnuts then lugging six boxes of them for five hours on the train up to Hirosaki in Aomori prefecture?! On a recent visit to said …

Comment by Pride

October 16, 2007 @ 12:06 pm

I wouldn’t be so dismissive of the signal to noise ratio of the (unnamed) forums. That’s where all of the real information on the Nova fiasco has be coming from.

What’s real info? Dozens of comments calling each other faggots and false rumors of cash injections? Too much chaff makes the wheat so ahrd to find that it’s useless.

And, DeOrio, MOS Burger rocks, but I wouldn’t expect a fan of McDonald’s-like crap to recognize a good burger.

KK fans are better at getting together for donuts than Nova employees are to fight for their own rights. Sad.

Comment by DeOrio

October 16, 2007 @ 2:23 pm

Haha. Of all the things I’ve ever written, I never expected my preference for Burger King over MOS would draw comments or criticism. I’ll bite, though. Shawn, agreed. It’s crap, but I eat a lot of junk. From BK to Matsuya to potato chips to cheap kaiten-zushi to Snickers bars and niku-man, I eat them all. Some garbage is better than others. (For the record, I don’t got to Krispy Kreme on the grounds that waiting over an hour for a dozen doughnuts makes one not unhealthy, but dumb and unhealthy.)

AS for the forums, I don’t deny that useful information comes up in them (and I don’t mean to single a certain unnamed forum out.) I must say, though, that I’m inclined to agree with Pride (although I would have put it a bit less forcefully.) I don’t think it’s at all accurate to say that all the real information comes from the forums or blog comments at all. The most crucial information has been accurate financial info and that has come almost exclusively from the mainstream press and (to self-promote) Ken’s analysis.

This is not to belittle the role of forums and blogs in general, though. There is a wealth of info in forums - and that is often where one hears things first. The trouble is, though, that you have to wade through a whole lot of Burger King and Krispy Kreme to get to the O-toro or steak. This can be off-putting.
I have a pseudo-theory about this, but it’d take up too much space here.

Comment by berihebi

October 17, 2007 @ 7:54 am

The forums are and have always been an unusual place in terms of Nova comment and opinions. It seems that ever since Nova became the major player in the Eikaiwa market in the early to mid-nineties, everyone including even Nova instructors have been wishing for it to fall over - despite their financial dependance on it. I can’t think of any other service provider that has been thought so little of by it’s employees and it’s kind of amazing that Nova has lasted this long and been as successful in that type of environment.
This is all reflected in forum comment. The old saying to be careful what you wish for applies here as the current group of Nova teachers, staff and students will unfortunately be the ones to bare the effects of a Nova collapse that has been looked forward to by many thousands since about 1994.
Personally, I like Becker’s burgers myself - good bread.

Comment by DeOrio

October 17, 2007 @ 11:23 am

Berihebi, I’d say Nova employees are already feeling the effects of Nova’s collapse, which is, unfortunately, no longer an “If,” but a “When.” I’m not sure I agree that Nova instructors have had an unusually strong desire to see their employer go under, though. I see a lot of comments in forums and on blogs expressing optimism, even now, when that optimism is bordering on idiocy. People disliking management and wishing for the company’s collapse are two different things.

I think young people working in any service industry would show a certain schadenfreude at the collapse of their companies. This feeling mightbe a bit strongerin the eikaiwa industry, but I don’t see much that makes me think Nova is an outlier there, other than its size, which doesn’t mean the feeling sronger, just more noticeable.

Becker’s, eh? That was my first favorite in Japan. I don’t know whether to be worried or impressed that JR East makes a decent fast food burger.

Comment by DeOrio

October 17, 2007 @ 11:54 am

OK, I’m inspired (and hungry.) My loose overall ranking of predominantly burder-serving chains in the greater Tokyo area (omitting those at which I haven’t eaten or don’t know):

1. Kua’Aina
2. Zats Burger
3. Freshness Burger
4. Becker’s
5. Wendy’s
6. Burger King
7. McDonald’s
8. MOS Burger
427. Lotteria

Comment by Mike P

October 17, 2007 @ 1:50 pm

MOS is bond!

1. MOS Green
2. Regular red MOS
3. Freshness
4. Burger King
5. Lotteria
6. Wendy’
I don’t know your #1 and 2, and have never had Becker’s (is that the same as Beck’s?) But I’m sure they’re all better than….

427. McDonald’s

Comment by berihebi

October 17, 2007 @ 1:55 pm

First Kitchen would give Lotteria a run for their money as the worst. However,the wonderful and unlimited condiments selection is a strong point.

Comment by DeOrio

October 17, 2007 @ 2:44 pm

A very good point. I’ve been to First Kitchen only once. I guess I’d suppressed the memory. I’ll put that at 428. It’s bad.

Comment by DeOrio

October 19, 2007 @ 4:41 pm

Speaking of Nova and food and causes.

Please join us at Big Ys Cafe in Yokohama Motomachi tomorrow (Saturday) night to drink and, in the process, contribute to the financial well-being and legal defense of Mr. Osayuwamen Idubor.

I know that Nova teachers were not paid today, but I also know that a lot of them are going to go out on Saturday night. If you’re a Nova employee going through this surreal experience, come out and join us - help up out a man who’s the “it could be worse” in your story. All you have to do is imbibe and talk (if you feel like it.)

Thanks. We hope to see each and every one of our readers there.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>