Tokyo Metropolitan Election Returns (Live Blogging, more or less)

Filed under: Japan in the News, Politics
Posted by Garrett DeOrio at 10:07 pm on Sunday, July 12, 2009

While the counting is far from over, returns for theMai Goto Tokyo Metrpolitan elections are coming in and it looks like a landslide for the DPJ.

Polls closed at 8:00 p.m. As of 10:00 p.m., according to NHK:
- The DPJ has won 41 seats and an unaffiliated candidate won, giving the opposition camp 42 seats so far
- The LDP is on pace to do much worse than the 48 seats it held, having won only 7 so far. It’s coalition partner New Komeito has 4.
- No other party has won a seat.
- The opposition leads 42 - 11 with 74 districts not yet reporting.

- The bizarre Happiness Realization Party (幸福実現党) got zero votes (so far) in Suginami, which is only slightly more than I would have predicted.
- Here in Nakano, DPJ first-timers swept, with former secretary to Lower House member Akira Nagatsuma, Nishizawa finishing first and Yoshida finishing second. An LDP candidate finished last here.
- An energetic 26 year-old, Kurishita, beat LDP oldie and local Secretary General Uchida in an apparently close one, despite Kunio Hatoyama speaking on behalf of Uchida.
- Former gravure model Mai Goto lost in Shinjuku.
- Ishihara (Nobuteru, not the Gov.) speaking for LDP. I don’t know why, but he reminds me of a reject from a Monty Python revival. LDP is the only party that does not have its logo and slogan behind its speaker, instead having the old school candidate list - they might not want people to see that tonight.

- Apparently 44% of the vote has gone to the DPJ as of 10:00.

10:15 p.m.
68 districts not reporting.
DPJ 44
LDP 10
Komeito 4
Unaffiliated 1
45-14 Opposition camp

10:33 p.m.
52 districts not reporting.
DPJ 46
LDP 18
Komeito 7
JCP 2
Unaffiliated 2
50-25 Opposition camp

- 64 seats are necessary for a majority. At this point, projections for the probably victorious DPJ are between 50 and 57 seats, not enough to run the show alone, but much better than the 34 seats the DPJ got last time and a big dropoff for the LDP any way you shake it.
- It seems the DPJ won their races resoundingly, while the squeakers went to the LDP or Komeito. A shovelful of early DPJ results came up, but the ruling camp is making up some ground as more of the races for which counting is necessary come in. That said, the opposition still has twice the old boys’ seat count so far.

- Poor Ishihara really looks like he wants to take his fake tan and go home. The opposition even looks better groomed than the ruling camp, which is saying something when you think that they have the JCP on their side.

- New DPJ man from Setagaya looks nervous as he can be - smile so forced, he could be in New Komeito, who have been startling the crap out of me every morning on my way to work by screeching “ohayo gozaimasu” at the top of their lungs as they bow in an inhumanly rapid and deep manner next to their orange-shirted sign holders, who all have painful-looking smiles and hair that doesn’t look lacquered, but doesn’t move, like less-shiny Jimmy Johnsons. (It’s an American football joke, sorry.) What percentage of the ¥1 Komeito charges for their fliers at rallies goes to hair products and manufacturers of blaze orange clothing?

Blaze orange - it’s not just for hunting anymore.

10:50 p.m.
33 districts not reporting.
DPJ 50
LDP 23
Komeito 15
JCP 4
Unaffiliated 2
56-38 Opposition camp

- In Suginami, the Happiness Realization Party has 1,000 votes. It’s scary that there are 1,000 people not only that dumb, but that spiteful of their fellow man. Let’s be clear, they’re a party of fearmongering to the ill-informed and not particularly bright, and bizarre, irrational ideology at the expense of the country, which makes them a bit worse than the Abe and his buddies in the LDP.

For more on the Happiness Realization Party, listen to the latest Seijigiri as you watch the results come in.

- While the LDP is winning seats, they have not finished first in any district so far. All of their seats are for second or third-place finishes or lower.

- New Komeito’s Takakura is listed as second in Nakano, having tied with Yoshida at about 10,500 votes. He has the aforementioned “smile” and hair.

- With the DPJ’s success, I’m looking for their Sugimura Taizo, but I haven’t seen him yet.

11:15 p.m.
12 districts not reporting.
DPJ 52
LDP 33
Komeito 21
JCP 7
Unaffiliated 2
61-54 Opposition camp

- Wow. No landlside, this. With the ruling camp taking so many of the closer races, it’s getting hot. The LDP really owes Komeito for doing what Komeito does - getting out the vote. I haven’t seen any demographics yet, but I’d bet the DPJ is suffering from the same thing more reformist or liberal parties always do, especially if they appeal to younger voters: Young people and liberals don’t vote.

- There was an LDP surge, but the results coming in now look like a race between the new religion Buddhists and the Communists.

- Hand it to NHK, they do try to keep some balance, they keep interviewing the SDP spokesman, as if it mattered that the SDP was going from zero seats to zero seats. They’re talking to one of the few members of the People’s New Party, too, who has the unfortunate habit of mumbling and talking through his teeth. Beats feeling the need to shout.

11:25 p.m.
7 districts not reporting.
DPJ 52
LDP 36
Komeito 22
JCP 7
Tokyo Life Network 1
Unaffiliated 2
62-58 Opposition camp

- The Tokyo Life Network, a new party last time around, got themselves a seat - a dropoff from the four they had.

- The ruling camp has gone from 70 to 58, the opposition from 55 to 62 so far. However, those second and third-place finishes are adding up to a close race. In the end, it doesn’t matter how much you win by or even if you don’t actually win (as in finish first) anywhere - a seat is a seat.
This is worrying as the LDP will take this as a message that the people still like what they’re doing, even though that might not actually have been true for years.

- The Opposition doesn’t quite have a chance to turn the tables, but it can come pretty close and can certainly get a majority.

- Music Japan is on now. Perhaps the only thing more insipid than lip-synched J-Pop is a vapid conversation about it complete with clips from the embarrassingly bad, self-consciously “cool” videos. It’s like an entire industry is stuck in Color Me Badd’s heyday.

11:36 p.m.
Six more to go.
DPJ 52
LDP 36
Komeito 22
JCP 7
Net 2
Unaffiliated 2
SDP 0
63-58 Opposition camp

- Shocking! Aya Ueto and her friends all like sweet foods. Now she’s performing a pseudo-ska song. Where’s the remote? . . . And Mute.

11:46 p.m.
Four more to go.
DPJ 54
LDP 36
Komeito 22
JCP 7
Net 2
Unaffiliated 2
SDP 0
65-58 Opposition camp

- And the DPJ and their allies have a majority. Goodbye, LDP/Komeito rule of Tokyo.

- For an amusing discussion that is at least partly on Happy Science, the inane cult behind the Happiness Realization Party, check out this thread on Mutant Frog. The group’s defender pretty much gives you all the proof you’ll need that my calling them an inane cult is probably an understatement.
Adamu has been liveblogging as well, starting about the same time I did.

12:05 a.m.
Two more to go.
DPJ 54
LDP 38
Komeito 22
JCP 7
Net 2
Unaffiliated 2
SDP 0
65-60 Opposition camp

- Well, not much will change with two votes left. From epic ineptitude on the national stage to deeply unpopular and boneheaded ideas more locally (Shinginko Tokyo = Money toilet to make even Keynes flinch), the LDP and, by extension, Komeito (as their power comes from their affiliation with the LDP) have apparently worn out their brand, but not as badly as I expected. I thought the opposition had a real shot at a full reversal, or close to it. That is, getting 69 or 70 seats.
It was telling that so very few first-place finishers were from the ruling coalition. If we can draw anything from these results at this point, it’s that the opposition’s margin of victory was greater than the seat count would show. I’m not going to toss around the word “mandate,” especially as the opposition’s victory was as much the ruling camp’s accomplishment as their own. Look for this to be at least a partial harbinger of what is to come next month in the general election. (Or at least most likely next month, could be a little bit later.)

- In an observation indicative of little, I was pleased to see that my voting-eligible neighbors chose not a single person who used the bad idea of Tokyo hosting the 2016 Olympics to campaign. My dream would be that the opposition realizes the prefecture should cut its losses and drop the idea, withdrawing the bid immediately, but that won’t happen.

12:20 a.m.
One more to go.
DPJ 54
LDP 38
Komeito 22
JCP 8
Net 2
Unaffiliated 2
SDP 0
66-60 Opposition camp

12:25 a.m.
And the final totals are:
DPJ 54
LDP 38
Komeito 23
JCP 8
Net 2
Unaffiliated 2
SDP 0
66-61 Opposition camp

. . . as New Komeito takes the last seat to be reported. Not a landslide, as I said above, but a clear majority and an even clearer victory for the forces of the opposition. As my colleague Ken Worsley points out, perhaps one of the best results of this election is that Governor Ishihara will have a much tougher time getting his less bright ideas through (like making a vanity project of highly dubious merit possibly the most high-profile endeavor in which the prefecture is involved.) Let’s hope the DPJ and their allies can do things both differently and better.

For the political nerds, the changes (old numbers to new numbers of seats):
DPJ: 35 -> 54
LDP: 48 -> 38
New Komeito: 22 -> 23
JCP: 13 -> 8
Net: 4-> 2
Unaffiliated: 3 -> 2
SDP: 0 -> 0
Other minor parties: 1 -> 0
Happiness Realization Party: N/A -> 0

So, the only unambiguously successful party was the DPJ, with all of the smaller parties stuck with the same duality, viz. influence (should they have any) going the opposite way of their numbers.

The DPJ’s success, though, is something to be proud of - a jump of 20 seats to 54, six more than the LDP had last time around, gives them the luxury of ignoring the Tokyo Life Network if they want to and keeping a bare majority. (I’m joking.) The fact that so many of the DPJ’s candidates were elected and that they did so well with relatively few candidates, bodes well for the national stage.

The more I think about it, though, the more I start to think that New Komeito might have gained a bit of power. Sure, their meal ticket can no longer bring home as much bacon, but they’ll be able to demand a larger share of what bacon there is unless they just split now that there’s not even a bare political reason to stay together unless the general election goes quite differently.

And with that, I bid you good night.

The Next Morning:

- Every New Komeito candidate, all 23 of them, was successful.
- Only four DPJ candidates did not win a seat.
- The LDP was the least successful party in percentages, with 20 of their candidates getting the cold shoulder from the voters of Tokyo.
- Make that the least successful other than the dwindling, disappearing SDP, whose role is unclear in the current political climate. Why do they even exist? Of course, the Happiness Realization Party also pulled a big zero, but their role is clear: they’re nuts. Cults need no other purpose.
- Actually, the LDP’s win percentage was better than Net’s, too. Net lost half of the races it entered.

- I corrected the DPJ changes. NHK said they’d had 34 seats, but the Yomiuri this morning said 35. Even with that adjustment, I have one more seat in the Tokyo total this time.


Related Posts:

13 Comments »

Comments may be subject to moderation and/or approval before appearing. There is no need to post the same comment twice. The site moderator may remove any comment he or she deems inappropriate, without notice.

Comment by Ken Worsley

July 12, 2009 @ 10:22 pm

Kurishita won in Chiyoda, right?

Too bad about Mai Goto.

0 votes for the nutters? I saw that their posters in my neighborhood had been vandalized. Faces ripped off, notes taped to them saying they were stupid and dangerous.

LDP posters around here have also been vandalized. Faces scratched out.

Comment by Ken Worsley

July 13, 2009 @ 12:29 am

Komeito actually gained a seat, to my surprise. Unsurprisingly, the communist party lost seats, down to 8 from 13. When are we going to see the next article about supposed increased support for the JCP?

Comment by Ken Worsley

July 13, 2009 @ 1:12 am

Crazy LDP justification I can’t wait to hear tomorrow:

“As the results came in, we gained a lot of ground on the opposition parties. If there had been more seats we would have eventually caught them and won. In that sense, we can say the DPJ won a short race, but the LDP will win in the long run.”

Even crazier LDP justification I can’t wait to hear tomorrow:

“Local election results have no bearing on national politics.”

The Ishihara Effect

I expect this to be his last term in office. The DPJ coalition majority could give him severe headaches over these last few years. What remains to be seen is if the assembly will continue simply rubber stamping the ideas of bureaucrats or if they are going to want a bigger say in forming policy.

Komeito

Komeito is obviously good at getting their people to go out and vote. They only gained one seat, but that was in the face of many expectations for them to lose a few. Will this give them more leverage with the LDP on the national stage, and if not - could it lead them to reconsider their alliance with the LDP?

I don’t think they have enough clout on the national stage to gain much leverage against the LDP, but the LDP is getting desperate. This should be interesting to watch.

A lot of people aren’t going to have fun at work tomorrow.

Comment by Sporcasta

July 13, 2009 @ 1:52 am

So why are you so hard on Happy Science, but not on the New Komeito which is Sokagakai? And why be hard on groups that want to improve peoples’ lives but not on the same old cynical political animals? Lets face it, the DPJ is just politicians who want power. The Happiness Realization Party is clear about what it wants to do.
And why hard on Mai Goto? People can change can’t they?

Comment by Ken Worsley

July 13, 2009 @ 2:14 am

Sporcasta, I cannot answer for Garrett, but I can tell you what I think. I am negative about Happy Science because it is batshit insane; the inclusion of the word science in their name strikes me as a punchline to an unfunny joke. But, I think that is true for any and all religions - they are all batshit insane, each and every one of them.

This is also only a single post, and not indicative of years worth of writing on Japanese politics. I have been hard on Komeito at time because I do not see an alliance with the LDP to be in concert with their stated goals.

You make a good point about political parties only wanting power - that is the very reason for their existence. All political parties, including Komeito and the Happiness Realization Party, are just politicians who want power. Of course, the HRP will never get any - as was clearly demonstrated by the election results.

As far as Mai Goto goes, I do not think anyone was being hard on her. I was hoping she would win.

Comment by Adamu

July 13, 2009 @ 7:05 am

Somehow in my excitement over the election I missed your liveblogging… good stuff.

I am very heartened that the happy party was not able to pick up any seats. Those guys are extreme!

Comment by Amathev

July 13, 2009 @ 8:10 am

SPORCASTA:
Religion shouldn’t belong in politics.

Comment by Deepspacebeans

July 13, 2009 @ 8:49 am

I actually find it highly unsurprising that the Komeito picked up a seat. With so many voters jumping ship on the LDP, they definitely stood to gain on this election. What did surprise me, however, was the loss of some seats on the part of the JCP, who I saw as being potentially able to give the komeito a bit of a run for their money this time around. I guess I just hang around with too many university students :P . Still, they stand to gain political power under a DPJ lead-minority as they may have to be counted on to occasionally pull together a majority vote.

Comment by Garrett DeOrio

July 13, 2009 @ 11:33 am

Deepspacebeans,
You could be forgiven for thinking the JCP would pick up some seats. After all, the rising popularity of the Communist Party was favorite trope of the Anglophone media on Japan for a while, never mind that it wasn’t based in reality. Likewise, a lot of people seem to like the way they do things - fewer, if any, noise trucks (at least around here), a little bit more tak about what they want to do, and some populist carrots. However, saying they seem decent is not the same thing as voting for them.

That said, you’re absolutely right that the DPJ will need the JCP to form a majority.

Sporcasta,
Ken said it pretty well. The HRP is incoherent and detached from reality. I don’t know about you, but provoking a nuclear war is not how I go about increasing my personal piece of mind. More important, the more I see Happy Science’s advocates and adherents defend Happy Science, the more painfully obvious it becomes that this is a cult that attracts and keeps members like any other cult. The accomplishments and ideas of its leader, added together, come out to nil. Worst of all, the group espouses nutjob ideas that are at direct odds with their other nutjob ideas.
Such people should be pitied, perhaps, but not encouraged and not given any kind of power. It might even be wise to see if they have relatives who can help them out around the house.

As for Komeito, they’re less batshit insane, but their stated goals are largely belied by the fact that they’re willing to team up with the LDP. As for New Komeito’s affiliation with Soka-Gakkai, what bugs me is not so much that they are essentially a wing of SGI, but that they deny it, which is an insult to everyone’s intelligence - they didn’t even bother to change the name of the party or many of its members before they came back as a different, independent group that has an affiliation with, but is in no way controlled by SGI.
My ass.

SGI is not dangerous (except maybe to their members) and New Komeito does have some god ideas, but the symbiosis between the religion and party is unsettling.

As for Mai Goto, I don’t think we here hard on her. We made fun of her to the extent that she deserved it. If you’re a former bikini model campaigning in a pink yukata, doing cutesy bikini model poses, and using a hazy Glamour Shot as your publicity photo, you’re not trying to change. Furthermore, if she had a plan or ideas, she didn’t do much to publicize them.

As for wanting her to win, one hand Ken is right - that would always give us something to talk about. On the other hand, I’d like to see qualified, able people running the ward, the city, the prefecture, and the country where I live. If Mai Goto was qualified and able, she did a good job of hiding it behind goofy poses.

Comment by rationalist

July 14, 2009 @ 1:45 am

Sporcasta:

Are you kidding? Happy Science is a cult and the Happiness Realization Party makes no sense. Nothing in their literature would lead to happiness. Abolition of all sales tax? It makes no sense. I would like to see Japan get rid of sales tax on food, but cutting all sales tax means there is no money for paying pensions. With a graying society, old people are not going to support this nonsense. It only takes money away from them.

Deepspacebeans:

What did surprise me, however, was the loss of some seats on the part of the JCP

Communism is not very popular these days. It sort of died out 20 years ago.

Comment by Ken Worsley

July 14, 2009 @ 6:37 pm

Garrett, Good points about Mai Goto. Nothing we saw suggested change. Sporcasta, let us know if you’ve seen otherwise.

Personally I think it was quite the opposite. She campaigned like a bikini model and was arrested only three months ago for distribution of indecent material.

http://npn.co.jp/article/detail/78075884/
http://www.sanspo.com/geino/news/090712/gnj0907120504011-n1.htm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izccsltZDtg
http://ameblo.jp/mai-goto/

Not sure what you’re talking about with “change”

Comment by mary sayre

July 15, 2009 @ 2:50 am

So glad to hear you again -it’s been a lon time. It’s good that Japan has so many elections for you to comment on. Most interestin about the model who iis running. Gram

Comment by Ken

July 16, 2009 @ 2:20 am

The Communist Party went from 13 to 8 seats in the Tokyo Assembly, a reduction of nearly 40% of their seats, and we’re still getting this from the foreign media:

Japanese turn to communists in downturn

The article tells us:

This increase in grass-roots support has been boosted by a manga version of Karl Marx’s “Das Kapital,” which sold more than 6,000 copies in the two days after it was released in December.

6,000 copies sold in a nation of 124 million people means nothing.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>